The Pencil-in-the-Ear Incident ✏️👂

The question "what does my brain feel like?" is one that most people resolve through reflection rather than direct physical investigation. TOM is not most people. Chapter 34 opens with TOM mid-experiment, approximately three centimetres into an ear canal that was not designed to accommodate HB pencils, discovering that the answer to his question is "painful" and "not at all what I expected."

This chapter carries the same principle as the impalement chapter — Chapter 25, the nailgun — but applied to a smaller, more sensitive, and harder to access part of the body. The rule is the same: leave it in, get professional help, don't try to extract it yourself. The ear has its own additional considerations that make this even more important.

📖 Chapter 34 — The Scenario

TOM stuck a pencil in his ear to feel his brain. The pencil is now lodged in the ear canal. TOM is screaming, hopping on one foot, and gesturing urgently. He does not appear to have learned anything useful about brain texture. What should you do?

A) Leave it in and get help immediately

Do not attempt to remove the pencil. Get TOM to A&E immediately. Removing it could cause more damage. This is ear surgery territory, not hallway territory.

B) Yank it out and slap him

You yanked it. Now he's deaf in one ear and furious. Rapid removal of a lodged object from the ear canal risks tearing delicate tissue and perforating the eardrum. 0 points.

C) Blow in the other ear

You blew. The other ear popped like bubble wrap. This is not a recognised medical technique for ear foreign body removal and has introduced pressure changes to an already-stressed auditory system. 0 points.

D) Shake him until it falls out

You shook him. The pencil is now deeper than your regrets. Gravity and shaking do not assist ear foreign body removal — they may assist the object's journey inward. 0 points.

Option A is correct — and the reason is the anatomy. The ear canal is narrow, curved, and lined with very delicate skin. At the end of it sits the eardrum: a thin membrane that is both fragile and essential. A pencil lodged in the ear canal is close to this membrane and potentially in contact with it. Attempting to remove the pencil — by pulling, blowing pressure from the other side, or shaking — risks pushing it further, tearing the canal lining, or perforating the eardrum. A perforated eardrum is painful, potentially affects hearing, and takes weeks to heal. Medical removal under direct vision with proper instruments takes minutes and doesn't do any of these things.

💡 The Core Rule

Anything stuck in an ear — pencils, beads, insects, cotton wool, small toys: do not attempt to remove it yourself. Keep the person calm, keep them still (don't let them hop around), and go to A&E. If the object is an insect that may still be alive, tilting the ear upward and putting a few drops of olive oil in can immobilise it — but the removal still happens at A&E.

"Ears are not pencil holders."

Why the ear is not a DIY zone

The ear canal is approximately 2.5cm long, curves gently inward, and narrows toward the eardrum. It's lined with skin that contains specialised cerumen (earwax) glands and is richly supplied with nerves — which is why objects in the ear cause disproportionate pain. At the end of the canal sits the tympanic membrane: the eardrum.

The eardrum is a thin, semi-transparent membrane roughly 8–10mm in diameter. It vibrates in response to sound and transmits those vibrations to the three tiny bones of the middle ear. It can be perforated by direct pressure, sudden pressure changes, or sharp objects — all of which are represented in the chapter's four options. A perforation is painful, can cause temporary hearing loss and tinnitus, and may take 6–8 weeks to heal naturally. Some require surgical repair.

Medical ear foreign body removal uses instruments specifically designed for the purpose, a light source, and direct vision through an otoscope. It's quick, safe, and causes none of the additional damage that improvised removal methods do. This is why option A is not just correct but significantly preferable to the alternatives.

The correct response

1. Do not attempt to remove the object

   Repeat this clearly to TOM, who will want to remove it immediately. The most important single action is not taking any action on the object itself.

2. Keep TOM calm and as still as possible

   Hopping around and gesturing vigorously risks the object moving further. Sit him down. Calm voices help. The situation is recoverable if handled correctly.

3. Go to A&E — don't wait for a GP appointment

   Ear foreign bodies are an A&E presentation. Don't call the GP and wait. Go directly. Most A&E departments deal with these regularly and quickly.

4. Special case: live insect in the ear

   If the foreign body is a live insect, tilting the ear upward and dripping a few drops of olive oil into the canal can immobilise it (stopping the distressing buzzing/movement sensation). The insect still needs to be removed professionally — the oil just makes the journey to A&E more bearable.

🚫 Never Do These With a Foreign Body in the Ear

• Pull or yank the object out — risks tearing the canal and perforating the eardrum

• Poke at it with cotton buds, tweezers, or fingers — may push it further in or cause additional injury

• Blow pressure into the other ear — does nothing helpful and may cause barotrauma to the second ear

• Shake the person to dislodge it — gravity works inward as readily as outward; shaking is not directional

• Pour water in to "float it out" — some objects (paper, sponge) absorb water and expand, making the situation significantly worse

🇬🇧 UK Context

• Go to A&E for any object lodged in the ear — this includes beads, insects, small toys, cotton wool, and pencils

• Call 999 if there is significant bleeding from the ear, severe dizziness, or signs that the object may have penetrated beyond the ear canal

• Children under 5 are the most common ear foreign body patients — small beads, food, and toy parts are the typical objects. The response is the same: go to A&E, do not attempt removal at home.

• Earwax — not a foreign body, but worth noting — should never be removed with cotton buds; they push wax further in. Earwax softening drops or irrigation at the GP are the correct approaches.

• TOM's specific question about brain texture via the ear canal: the brain is not accessible via the ear. The ear canal ends at the eardrum. Beyond that are the middle and inner ear structures. The brain is elsewhere and is not palpable via this route under any circumstances.

The broader lesson from Chapter 34

Chapter 34 applies the impalement principle — leave it in, get professional help — to a smaller and more intimate context. The ear canal is exactly the kind of space where the instinct to "just get it out" is strongest and most dangerous. It's close, it's painful, and it seems like it should be accessible. But the anatomy makes improvised removal significantly more risky than leaving the object in place and getting appropriate help.

TOM's tip encodes the preventive lesson better than any detailed anatomy: ears are not pencil holders. They are not storage space, probes, or investigation tools. They are auditory organs with a delicate terminal membrane that objects should not approach. The correct use of a pencil is writing. The correct use of an ear is hearing. These are separate activities.

🚨 When to Call 999 Instead of Going to A&E

Call 999 rather than driving to A&E if: there is significant bleeding from the ear canal, the person is severely dizzy or vomiting uncontrollably, there are signs of serious head injury alongside the ear injury, or you have any reason to believe the object has penetrated beyond the ear canal. For a pencil lodged in a conscious, stable TOM — A&E directly is appropriate. But if TOM seems significantly unwell, call first.

Want to get latest updates on new books?

SubscRibe to our mailing list below

© 2025. All rights reserved.